Cookie Butter Muddy Buddies - The BEST Recipe Ever! (2024)

Created On: November 6, 2019&nbsp|Updated: April 18, 2022|By Kelsey|2 Comments

Cookie Butter Muddy Buddies is a recipe that will melt in your mouth. It is a fun variation to the classic muddy buddies recipe. This cookie butter puppy chow aka muddy buddies will win over a crowd.

I love this cookie muddy buddies recipe and I am very sure that your house guests will love to munch on this scrumptious dessert too. Who doesn’t love chocolate during the holidays? With its creamy peanut butter and soft, melted chocolate, it’ll be gone on the table in a few minutes!

If you have some cookie butter on hand and wonder how to use it up, give this recipe a try. I mean this could even be transformed into a Biscoff muddy buddies recipe as well.

Cookie Butter Muddy Buddies

If you want to learn how to make muddy buddies with cookie butter or Biscoff, behold this easy and incredible recipe. I will transform your life in a way you could only dream of with this dessert!

I am an Amazon Affiliate so if you shop and order through one of my links, I will earn a commission on sales.

is Cookie Butter

Cookie butter is a wonderful cross between say Biscoff and Nutella. Cookie Butter is made with crunchy spiced shortbread style biscuits, that have a faint gingerbread flavor. Now you can buy all kinds of cookie butter so make sure to read before you purchase!

If you are googling

• Ways to use cookie butter
• What is Cookie Butter used for
• Substitutions for Cookie Butter

I will are all my knowledge with you to help you master this recipe, and use up that cookie butter in your pantry.

What Can I Substitute For Cookie Butter In This Muddy Buddies Recipe

• Biscoff
• Nutella
• Or even Peanut Butter

How To Make Muddy Buddies

1. Start by greasing a cookie sheet and laying out parchment paper.
2. You then add your cookie butter, chips, and shortening or butter to a bowl. Microwave till melted, stir as needed.
3. Once melted pour and mix in with Chex cereal. Continue stirring until evenly coated. Then add your powdered sugar into a bag, and shake to coat your cereal.
4. Spread out onto the baking sheet and let dry for an hour.

How To Store Leftover Cookie Butter Muddy Buddies

You can take all your leftover muddy buddies and store them in a covered dish or even in a sealable Ziploc bag. Then store it on the counter and much whenever you get a craving.

It will store for around a week on the counter. Use your best judgment on if you feel you need to toss it out or not.

More Chex Dessert Recipes

• Original Puppy Chow
• Holiday Chex Bars
• Lemon Puppy Chow
• Candy Corn Puppy Chow

Can I Use Something Else Besides White Chocolate Chips

You are more than welcome to use cinnamon chips if you have them on hand. They are a bit harder to find but they are such a tasty warm spice flavor to add to your muddy buddies recipe. Just melt the chips just like the vanilla.

How to Melt Chocolate Mixture Without Microwave for Muddy Buddies

You can use a double boiler or even use an Instant Pot as a double boiler. Just heat on low and slowly melt your chocolate mixture until melted and nice and creamy! You don’t have to use the microwave if you would prefer another method. The key is to just stir often and stir smooth. It will still come out as good once you pour the chocolate over the cookies.

What Type Of Chex Cereal To Use For Muddy Buddies

I prefer to use Rice Chex for Muddy Buddies. I find it offers a nice light crunch factor that I can’t get over. You could use corn or the wheat Chex if you prefer, or do a blend of them.

Want more holiday dessert recipes

• Christmas Frosted Graham Crackers | Here is a frosted graham cracker that is a fun holiday snack. A great after-school snack or treat for your family.
• Penguin Brownies | These brownies are a festive Christmas dessert that is kid-friendly. Penguin-shaped brownies!
• Christmas Brownie Trees | A Christmas tree dessert that is calling your name. Frosted brownies that are shaped like a Christmas tree.

I hope you’ll enjoy making this cookie buddies recipe! This is definitely a perfect addition to the sweet holiday treat you’re looking for.

Reader Interactions